Incredible value. Immediate payment.

How it Works

  1. 1

    Tell us about your piece

    Include photos and any documents or certificates. Detailed information improves our level of service.

  2. 2

    Book a private appointment

    Choose a date and time to meet privately with a Vaultly expert, or ship insured for free. The evaluation is free, with no obligation to sell.

  3. 3

    Meet an expert, receive an offer

    Once we review your piece, we make a purchase offer. There are no fees or commissions.

  4. 4

    Get paid

    Receive immediate payment by bank transfer.

Get started
A tray of pre-owned gold jewelry
Cartier, Tiffany and Van Cleef & Arpels jewelry

Why Vaultly?

Vaultly was founded in 2009 to bring honesty and expertise to pre-owned luxury jewelry. Today we are trusted buyers of Cartier, Tiffany & Co. and Van Cleef & Arpels by collectors, estates and private clients.

Whether selling or buying, you receive expert guidance and complete discretion. Our in-house gemologists use the latest market data to make a fair offer — and we pay immediately.

Since 2009

Buying fine jewelry

38,000+

Pieces purchased

$0

Fees or commissions

Same day

Payment by bank transfer

As featured in

ForbesThe New York TimesVogueBloombergTown & CountryFinancial Times

Rated by our clients

Thousands of verified reviews from sellers and members

4.9 / 5

Trustpilot

Excellent · 2,400+ verified reviews

A+

Better Business Bureau

Accredited business since 2011

4.8 / 5

Google Reviews

1,100+ verified reviews

Featured Recent Acquisitions

Vaultly has purchased over 38,000 pieces of pre-owned jewelry

Van Cleef & Arpels Vintage Alhambra bracelet, 5 motifs

Van Cleef & Arpels

Vintage Alhambra bracelet, 5 motifs

Rhodium-plated 18k white gold with diamonds. Five signature Alhambra motifs, each framed by the Maison’s delicate gold beads.

Cartier LOVE bracelet, classic model, paved, 10 diamonds

Cartier

LOVE bracelet, classic model, paved, 10 diamonds

18k yellow gold with pavé diamonds. Cartier’s iconic screw motifs meet brilliant diamond detailing in the classic LOVE design.

Tiffany & Co. Tiffany HardWear graduated link necklace

Tiffany & Co.

Tiffany HardWear graduated link necklace

18k yellow gold with pavé diamonds. Graduated gauge links bring bold proportions and diamond brilliance to Tiffany’s HardWear collection.

Our promise to you

Selling or buying fine jewelry is a matter of trust. These are the guarantees behind every Vaultly transaction.

Lifetime authenticity guarantee

Every piece is verified by our in-house, GIA-trained gemologists. If a piece we sell is ever proven not authentic, we refund you in full — for life.

Free, fully insured shipping

Every shipment is covered door-to-door by Lloyd's of London insurance, at no cost to you.

No obligation, ever

Evaluations are free. If you decline our offer, your piece is returned to you insured, at our expense.

Immediate payment

Accept an offer and you are paid the same day by bank transfer. No fees, no commissions, no waiting.

Complete discretion

Your details and your pieces are never shared. Appointments are private and one-to-one.

14-day returns for buyers

Members who purchase from a monthly release have 14 days to return a piece for a full refund, no questions asked.

Authenticated, four times over

No piece is listed or purchased until it passes every step of our authentication process.

  1. 01

    Gemologist inspection

    Every piece is examined under magnification by GIA-trained gemologists.

  2. 02

    Hallmark & serial verification

    Maker's marks, hallmarks and serial numbers are checked against house archives.

  3. 03

    Stone certification

    Diamonds and gemstones are graded and matched to their original certificates.

  4. 04

    Final sign-off

    A second senior expert countersigns every authentication before a piece is listed.

In their words

“I was nervous about selling my mother's Cartier bracelet online. Vaultly's expert walked me through every step, and the offer was far above the two local quotes I had.”

Margaret H.

Sold a Cartier Love bracelet · New York

“The insured shipping kit arrived the next day, and the money was in my account within hours of accepting the offer. Completely painless.”

David R.

Sold a Tiffany & Co. tennis bracelet · London

“As a buyer, the lifetime authenticity guarantee is why I come back. Every piece arrives exactly as described, with full paperwork.”

Sofia L.

Member since 2021 · Paris